Critiquing the Alt-Right from the Right

It is said to have no enemies to the right. This is sound advice in a leftist-dominated modernity. But it has also been said that the Alt-Right inevitably ends up leftwards of reaction and that is exactly what has happened.

The greatest strength of the Alt-Right is also its weakness: it has no core. No core equals strength because when one head is chopped off three more will grow in its place. No core equals weakness because emotionally driven movements are ephemeral. The Alt-Right is bound together by truth in the face of lies by SJW’s and cucks which means it is defined by that which it opposes. Since leftism will inevitably collapse that which binds together the Alt-Right will also inevitably collapse. The angry teenager may scream he does not need his parents, but he always does.

Many Alt-Righters will disagree and say that there is very much a core to Alt-Right philosophy to subsequently argue among each other over what those beliefs are. I have identified 2 core Alt-Right beliefs:

  1. Nature trumps nurture.
  2. We have to fight for change.

Point 1 is the mainstreaming of human biodiversity. What used to be only whispered in closed rooms is now shouted loudly for all to hear: Diversity + Proximity = War. Multiculturalism is a scam and the Alt-Right is effectively pointing it out by weaponising everything we know about genetics and shoving the obvious conclusions in your face.

Unfortunately pointing out the problem does not a solution make. If you go down the road of genes you end up with white supremacy, for which I am not in the slightest bit allergic yet for which I have some reservations. Africa for the blacks, Asia for the yellows, the West for the whites! Yes but who are the whites? What is this racial purity you are talking about and who really is loyal to whites as a tribe? Hillary Clinton is white. I see whites fucking each over all the time. Man I’d rat out an Italian white for a couple of bucks no problem. Hell I’d even rat out a Dutch white if I got away with it and the reward was high enough. The concept of Whiteness as a rallying point is fantasy land stuff. Muh whiteness is a Schelling point for rightists to signal temporary allegiance just as much as global warming is temporary allegiance signalling for leftists.

The entire white supremacy angle is a pushback to the leftist scam that is ‘racism’. Angry parents shout ‘racist!’, angry teenager shouts ‘reality is racist!’ Angry teenager is right, but still a teenager.

Point 2 is where Alt-Righters show balls and Reactionaries show vaginas. Or so it is said. But the Puritan hypothesis is true and the puritan hypothesis says that democracy is set up to fail. You can not meaningfully improve a democracy through democratic means. Yes you can give the patient a new liver, but it seems this patient has already passed away. Reactionaries are cynical in this way. Alt-Righters are more idealistic and passionate. But again, so is the teenager. If the Puritan hypothesis holds we will not see any structural change in Western government for the better. Some exceptional men might halt the downfall, but down it will fall.

Alt-Righters and reactionaries want to feel hope and not despair. But on a long enough timescale the Alt-Righters will feel despair when the wall of bureaucrats turns out to be immovable. Which does not mean you should lose all hope — just keep it real.

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “Critiquing the Alt-Right from the Right

  1. ” But the Puritan hypothesis is true and the puritan hypothesis says that democracy is set up to fail”
    I tend to lean reactionary over alt right but while MM had a lot of great critiques his thesis is not proved yet taken as gospel. This is a problem because its an excuse to do nothing.Lets start with the fact the as we speak tens of millions of non whites are invading the west and this will mean our being conquered so all hopes about future tech are garbage, even if we had another couple decades which we don’t it would not be enough time for the type of tech that reactionaries hope will save them. even if it were available in time and as powerful as hoped the cathedral will have it first and the cathedral is increasingly run by non whites to the extent it is run by whites they are whites that seem intent to commit suicide and take the rest of us with them or whites who do not identify say jews or Russian and Asians spies working against the west. so forget tech
    The other excuse for doing nothing and why it will be ok so not sheer cowardice is muh collapse. The cathedral is not going to collapse yes it should but it wont they have succeeded in getting the entire world heavily invested in the casino so no economic catastrophe is going to completely take it out in fact any sort of ‘collapse ‘ will be seen by the cathedral as an excuse to take the police state to the next level.They are well on their way to replacing the white men in the armed branches of govt as well as arming the rest of the civil service they have well tested how fear of losing ones job commands obedience, how much more obedient when there are no jobs outside protecting the cathedral.
    But they really dont have to wait for a crisis/ opportunity they have the cathedral and have in the lasy decade established that there is no rule of law other than what they say it is and have been making changes based on their new power, any day now free speech will be declared a crime as it already is in europe and blogs like this and the ability to communicate and organize will be gone, and we will be criminals. lets face it if they cared enough they would arrest us now and nothing could stop them nor would anyone try. oh some of those racists were arrested well surely they deserved it.who in the west would defend us and what could they do.
    So we are in a situation where we are going to die or be enslaved as people within decades, and reaction says well nothing can be done because moldbug told us yada yada.
    You know even if that were true a man would die fighting. you talk about making oneself worthy to rule ans assuming power as if davos is going to call you one day in exasperation and plead with you to take over. This is absurd. you want to know how men became worthy to rule historically – and you monarchist larper’s should really listen up. They fought like men and conquered their enemies and took over. Thats it, And thats whats going to happen again, maybe it will be niggers maybe Chinese maybe some alt right hero but it wont be a reactionary because you wont fight so you wont rule And this is important because there is still an opening. no it may not be a new civil war it might be more like Snowden and Assange or some 4g hybrid but at some point whites will fight because they will finally have to face whats up, if you dont agree with alt right then all the more reason to get in the fight so you will be in a position and worthy of assuming power. The alt right is correct perhaps for the wrong reasons but still race is the one organizing principle that could possibly change things mainly because its the primary weapon the left is using.Frankly I dont really see the alt right as particularly socialist in fact im pretty sure they actually have a alt left for the few that are actually socialist. As to this what does it mean to be white whos white? come please this is a leftist argument whites are white europeans are whites what are seriously suggesting race doesnt exist? are you going to use the leftist argument to argue all the way from the Bosphorus to greenland. sure we all can hope that france tries to remain french the basqes basqe the poles polish etc but reality is some of the most successful whites are mutts as in the anglosphere. And dont even start with this elitist hajinal line crap think for a moment about who is outside the hajinal line and where the precious nordic races myself included would be without – the roman empire the greek civilization the byzantine the unted states the Celtic hallstat culture of which we all owe a debt. Italy has the highest IQ in Europe and third highest in the world where do you think the AKZ jews got their smarts

    Now lets move on to the democracy issue, ok MM had a point but its not as major as you make out.
    the first problem is you have no alternative. Monarchy is rubbish there was a reason we got rid of it , a good man is hard to find and the chances of his son being one also are next to nil. and the chances of him being a good king and also able to kick the asses of all comers is nil. Besides the history HBD of Europeans is we dont really do kings well we are too smart and independent we suffer them occasionally out of expediency until they become tiresome. This idea of AI robots ruling us so not even worth replying to. This idea of cutting the world up into feifdoms and giving the like of Gates and zuckerberg the power of life and death over all within the boundaries is well so incredibly stupid it no wonder no one has even bothered to try to flesh out how it would actually work since MM threw it out. Maybe because reaction is mostly betas these things make sense Men like myself will never accept being ruled and men like myself will be doing the ruling because well thats what alphas do. The best you can hope for if you want something more sophisticated than baronies is something along the lines of democracy. shut the fuck up faggot im talking. the first great thing about a democracy is like whiteness everyone already knows what it is you neednt try and invent a new religion or type of government and convince the world to try your larp. Another great thing is the cathedral has already shown you how you can have a fully functioning democracy and still the elites can do whatever the fuck they want just by mind fucking the proletariat. Imagine how much easier that will be when you no loger have to mind fuck the citizens to go against deeply ingrained HBD instincts their own interests their own lying eyes and suffer results that suck.Another great thing about democracy is it was designed like capitalism to respond like evolution to changing conditions its our kind of government [yes some things went wrong, some things have gone wrong with capitalism are you going to get rid of capitalism too?} Another great thing about democracy is it isnt actually broken,at least not in the way you allege. Theres not mobs of white proles out in the street with pitchforks demanding free shit [ok france but its france] In fact proles have been the ones protesting multicultural communism its proles that oppose welfare and immigration and all the deviancy of leftism, in fact on the national level its the second world nations like Estonia Poland Hungary that are opposing global leftism. its elite intellectuals like yourselves pushing this anti HBD weird experimental culture something about IQs over 130 make people really stupid and want to experiment on other -you now crazy idea like cameralism.
    So whats wrong with democracy? well MM was close people who do not pay taxes [and some other social contributions like military service] should not be voting on how to spend those taxes. no representation without taxation. Think for a minute if only net tax payers could vote and only on the taxes they paid so no debt to be taken out and voted on by people who will not be paying that debt off. yes a balanced budget. do you think even if the voters were the leftiest of leftys and could vote on the budget itself line by line that leftism would lasy five minutes if lefty soccar moms had to actually pick between say AP courses for their bright kids and free head start babysitting for crack hoes, between trillions for immigration wage subsidies and a police force. no leftism would die in the cradle because leftism is built on the lie of free money. other people’s money borrowed money vague government money the idea that there is no limit to money so no choices ever need to be made.
    Now this is something [unlike cameralism] that people intuitivly get and their monkey brains intuitivly are on board with niggers know they are ‘getting over’ whites know they are being gotten over on but they hold off if told they can get in on the looting. in short it would not take an impossible effort to change the structure to make the government owned by the productive. this is in essence what moldbug proposes that owners take better care than renters you neednt go back to king arthur to do that or try and sell some new fad idea that will be incompatible with the HBD realities of the european people.
    And as for the proletariat they want to be ruled in a sense and in another sense they are owners in these nations of ours elon musk didnt actually build that – and I say this as a randian objectivist in a sense, but the reality is you cant invent something like an Iphone and sell it successfully without the infrastructure of a western nation in place to support you every step of the way, now does musk or gates or jobs deserve approximately as much cash as they have gotten from their efforts sure, but to pretend that the idaho farm boy manning the nuclear silos and battleships that patrol the china sea did not also contribute, or the cop or judge or professor and truck driver we all contribute.now thats a moral theory of property but lets be honest property is a product of violent ability and the people always hold the upper hand in that game.
    Something is going wrong with capitalism when all the little guys can be cut out the nation looted the profits offshored. Ill say it again at least until moldbug and some other influences and events this past decade i have always been a very hard core capitalist i still am. but we have to face some things one is capitalists often go for the short money, [this too undermines MMs patchwork thesis and monarchy history supports this] capitalist cant survive without USG and western civ yet they are destroying them for short money we could give thousands of macro and micro examples, another thing is HBD is telling us more than the stupidity of niggers one of these things is we as consumers do not actually act rationally all te time and some of us are not even smart enough to reason.Yes we love us some capitalism but why is that? we love how elegantly efficiently it gives us a better life, in other words we like it for what it does for us not for it own self. yes sure we admire its machinery but if it didnt do anything for us we would not admire it. Therefore capitalism is in service to us and our needs come before its. no im not suggesting a little teeny bit of socialism we all know how that ends i am suggesting we cant for the sake of theoretical beauty let capitalism do things like destroy western civilization or say the environment to pick one fraught with leftis bullshit but a little true. capitalism needs little tweaks here and there so does democracy and soon as we can we will be tweaking evolution to get rid of some traits behaviors that are no longer serving us in this environment. .

    1. Everyone on this side of the internet wants to fight, not do nothing. Question is how to fight. My trust in democracy is very low so my investment in democracy is very low. I’ll tell my friends and family to vote Geert Wilders and that is about it.

      The argument that you can redirect democracy and use it for the greater good to me sounds like Boromir telling the fellowship that they should use the ring against Sauron.

  2. WELL YOU WOULD BE THE FIRST NEO REACTIONARY I HAVE MET THAT WOULD FIGHT DO NOTHINGNESS IS MORE WHAT THE SCHISM WITH ALTRIGHT WAS ABOUT THAN THE RACE STUFF WHICH CAME LATER AFTER THE hrX IDEA WAS ABANDONED. iM NO HUGE FAN OF DEMOCRACY iM A FAN OF THINGS THAT CAN ACTUALLY WORK. ROBOTS KINGS COLLAPSES PATCHES EXIT ARE ALL FANTASY. THERES NO PLACE TO EXIT LAND WONT LAST FIVE MINUTES IN CHINA IF WAR BREAKS OUT. IF YOU CAN TALK PUTIN INTO GIVING YOU KALINGRAD AND HE CAN SURVIVE HOW LONG ARE THOSE SHOTS. VOICE IS ABOUT OVER THEY ARE PULLING THE PLUG ANY MINUTE THAT LEAVES WAR VOICE EXIT WAR, WAR IS REALLY HARD AT THIS POINT I FORM A MOSSAD AND GO DEVIANT BUT RACE WAR IS HALFWAY DECENT STRATEGY MOSTLY BECAUSE THEY ARE HELPING SO HARD TO BRING IT ABOUT AND ITS SO PRIMAL. IF I WERE A HIGH iq NRX I WOULD WANT TO BE INVOLVED SO I COULD INFLUENCE END GAME
    bUT THE DEMOCRACY IS DOOM THING IRKS ME IN THE SENSE THAT THE CASE IS NOT PROVEN YET THE ASSERTION TAKEN SO ABSOLUTELY, AND TAKEN BY THE VERY PEOPLE WHO SWEAR THE CATHEDRAL CONTROLS EVERYTHING AS IT DOES AND THE MAIN THING IT CONTROLS IS HOW PEOPLE THINK ABOUT WHAT RULERS ARE DOING AND HOW THEY VOTE FOR WHAT RULERS WANT WHICH MEANS NO MATTER HOW BAD SOMETHING TURNS OUT TEH PEOPLE CANT BLAME THE RULERS BECAUSE THEY WERE FOR IT AND VOTED FOR IT. IN OTHER WORDS DEMOCRACY IS NOT WHAT IT SEEMS IN THE CATHEDRAL AGE THE CATHEDRAL IS BRILLIANT IT JUST NEEDS TO BE USED TO RULE ACCORDING TO REALITY AND NOT LEFTIST COMMIE MULTICULTI. IF THERE WERE EVIDENCE THAT DEMOCRACY WAS ACTUALLY WORKING AND THE PROLETARIAT WERE VOTING FOR LEFTISM I WOULD AGREE WITH MM BUT THE PROLES VOTE AGINST LEFTISM AND THE ELITES COUNTERMAND VOTES BY COURT ORDER BY REGULATION BY REVOTING UNTIL VOTE COMES THERE WAY BY IMPORTING NEW VOTERS THERE IS ZERO EVIDENCE DEMOCRACY IS CAUSING LEFTISM DEMOCRACY IS SIMPLY ONE OF THE SOCIAL CONSTRUCTS LIKE RELIGION CLASS RACE THAT MARXISM USED TO FURTHER ITS GOALS AND LIKE CHRISTIANITY WHEN LEFTISM IS DONE WITH IT LEFTISM WILL TOSS IT TO THE CURB LIKE ITS OTHER DEAD HORSES.
    ILL TELL YOU WHAT CAUSES LEFTISM ONCE A CIVILIZATION IS OPTIMIZED THE GENERATIONS FROM THEN ON HAVE NO WAY TO MAKE THEIR MARK THERE IS LITTLE GLORY IN SIMPLY MAINTAINING A CIVILIZATION AS TIMES CHANGE A BIT BRIGHT RICH KIDS WANT TO DO BIG THINGS AND SO THEY CAST ABOUT FOR PROJECTS BUT THIS IS NOW A SPOILED GENERATION THEY ARE LAZY THEY HAVE NEVER EXPERIENCED HOW DEADLY MISTAKES CAN BE HOW SETBACKS CAN TAKE GENERATIONS TO OVERCOME SO THEY ARE CARELESS THEY FIND WHAT THEY THINK IS A PROBLEM BECAUSE ITS NOT PERFECT AND THEIR WORLD IS PERFECT THEY ASSUME THIS IS AN OVERSIGHT UPON WHICH THEY CAN MAKE THEIR MARK ON THE WORLD WHEN IN REALITY IT IS SIMPLY THE POINT OF DIMINISHING RETURN AND SO THEY PROCEED TO DIMINISH RETURNS AND THEN SOLVE UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES WITH NEW PROJECTS. UNREAL MONEY IS WHY THEY CAN NOT MEASURE THEIR RETURN ACCURATELY, AS OUT WORLD BECOMES SO COMPLICATED IT IS ALSO IMPOSSIBLE FOR MANY TO EVEN UNDERSTAND THE COMPLEXITIES AND WHAT HAS BEEN DONE AND OF COURSE THERE REALLY ARE COMMUNISTS OR THESE DAYS RACIAL REDISTRIBUTIONISTS WHO DO ACXTUALLY DO THEIR STUFF AS WELL BUT MOSTLY ITS SPOILED IDIOTS .

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s